American Express Hilton Honors Surpass American Express Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
American Express Hilton Honors Surpass
$150/yr


American Express Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
$650/yr
Every $1 · two cards
American Express Hilton Honors Surpass earns more in 3 of 9 categories · American Express Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant in 5
- Dining6×2.4¢ per $13×2.25¢ per $1
- Groceries6×2.4¢ per $12×1.5¢ per $1
- Gas6×2.4¢ per $12×1.5¢ per $1
- Flights3×1.2¢ per $13×2.25¢ per $1
- Hotels3×1.2¢ per $12×1.5¢ per $1
- Everything else3×1.2¢ per $12×1.5¢ per $1
Value per $1 uses the same point values as Discover Value: cash back at face value, points at Perqt's value for each program. Rates that apply all the time are shown, with caps and booking sites named; limited-time, spend-threshold and pick-one bonuses are in each card's full review. Annual fees and welcome offers are not counted here.
Fees, welcome offers & benefits
American Express
Hilton Honors Surpass
- Annual fee
- $150
- Network
- amex
- Welcome value
- ~$520
- Min spend
- $3,000 / 6mo
Top earning rates
- 12×Hotels and resorts within the Hilton portfolio · Hilton Honors
- 12×A hotel or resort within the Hilton portfolio · Hilton Honors
- 6×U.S. restaurants · Hilton Honors
- 6×U.S. supermarkets · Hilton Honors
Key benefits
- Free Night Reward (Spend Tier) · $300
- $200 Hilton Credit · $50
- Global Assist® Hotline · $0
- Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance · $0
- Hilton Honors® Gold Status · $0
American Express
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
- Annual fee
- $650
- Network
- amex
- Welcome value
- ~$750
- Min spend
- $6,000 / 6mo
Top earning rates
- 6×Hotels participating in Marriott Bonvoy® · Marriott Bonvoy
- 3×Restaurants worldwide · Marriott Bonvoy
- 3×Flights booked directly with airlines · Marriott Bonvoy
- 2×All other eligible purchases · Marriott Bonvoy
Key benefits
- Free Night Award · $640
- American Express Venue Collection · $250
- Fee Credit for Global Entry or TSA PreCheck® · $120
- $100 Marriott Bonvoy Property Credit · $100
- Brilliant Dining Credit · $25
Wondering which one is right for your wallet?
Spec sheets can't tell you which card actually earns more for the way you spend. Perqt connects to your wallet, runs the math against your real transactions, and tells you which of these two — or another card entirely — gives you the biggest annual uplift.
Get my personal answer